A Barrie retailer asked us a simple question last month: should I sell on Shopify, or get a custom website built? The honest answer is that it depends on what you sell, how often your products change, and who is going to run the store day to day. Here is how the year one math usually breaks down.
What Shopify really costs
Shopify charges a monthly subscription, plus transaction fees on each sale unless you use its own payment system. Then there are apps. Most stores end up adding a few: one for reviews, one for email, maybe one for shipping or bookings. Each app is a small monthly fee on its own, and they add up quietly.
The upside is real. You can be selling within days, not weeks. Inventory, checkout, and discount codes all work out of the box. If you change products often, or run seasonal sales, doing it yourself in Shopify is straightforward and you do not need a developer for every change.
Shopify makes the most sense when you sell a lot of different products, update them yourself, and want to be live fast.
What a custom website really costs
A custom site usually costs more up front and less per month after that. At 705 AI, websites start at $499, and there is no monthly platform fee baked into the build itself. You pay for hosting and for maintenance only if you want it (our maintenance plans run $50 to $150 a month, and they are optional).
The trade off is flexibility in the other direction. A custom site can be built exactly around how you sell, whether that is bookings, quotes, or a small catalogue that rarely changes. But adding a full online store with dozens of products later is a bigger project than starting on Shopify in the first place.
A custom site makes the most sense when your product list is small and stable, when you mostly need customers to call, book, or request a quote, or when you want a site that is built to be found in AI search from day one.
The question to ask before you choose
Forget the platform for a minute and answer this: who updates the store, and how often?
If the answer is "me, every week," Shopify's monthly cost buys you independence, and it is usually worth it. If the answer is "hardly anyone, and the products barely change," a custom site's higher up front cost and lower monthly cost usually wins in year one, and keeps winning after that.
One more thing to check either way: can customers find you when they ask ChatGPT or Siri for what you sell? A store nobody can find is expensive on any platform. That is what our free AI visibility audit checks, before you spend anything on a rebuild.
The bottom line
Shopify wins on speed and on stores you run yourself. A custom site wins on monthly cost and on a site shaped exactly around your business. Pick the one that matches how you actually work, not the one with the flashier demo.
Not sure which camp you fall into? Run the free audit at 705ai.ca/audit, or reach out at 705ai.ca/contact, and we will give you a straight answer in a 30 minute discovery call. No obligation, no pressure.
